Description
The Safariland Comp I J-S5 is built for revolver owners who want speed without bulk. This injection-molded speedloader holds six rounds of .44 Magnum or .44 Special and works with S&W N-Frame revolvers including the Model 29, 624, and 629, plus it's compatible with Ruger Redhawk and Colt Anaconda .44 Magnum revolvers.
What sets this loader apart is how it functions. The spring-loaded mechanism holds rounds securely, and when you align them with your cylinder and press down, the cartridges automatically release when they contact the ejector rod. There's no knob to turn or extra steps required during the reload, making it faster than twist-knob designs. The small, low-profile knob keeps the overall profile minimal, which appeals to people carrying revolvers or practicing with speed reloads at the range.
Build quality matters here. The polymer body is rigid and durable, with a stamped steel gear at the base of the ratchet for controlled, consistent operation. This isn't flimsy plastic. The compact design means it doesn't take up much room in a pouch or range bag compared to larger loaders. However, keep in mind that depending on your specific revolver's grips, you might need to make minor adjustments or switch to different grips for full clearance. It's not a deal-breaker, just something to verify before your first range trip.
Key Specifications
- Model Number: J-S5
- UPC: 781602097239
- Caliber: .44 Magnum, .44 Special
- Capacity: 6 Rounds
- Construction: Injection-molded polymer with stamped steel ratchet
- Release Mechanism: Automatic spring-loaded release
- Compatible Firearms: S&W N-Frame (Models 29, 624, 629), Ruger Redhawk .44 Magnum, Colt Anaconda .44 Magnum
- Profile: Low-profile compact design
- Color: Black
- Hand Orientation: Ambidextrous
- Manufacturer: Safariland
Frequently Asked Questions
Will this speedloader work with my revolver's current grips?
It depends on your specific grips and revolver model. Safariland recommends checking clearance before relying on it for shooting. Some grips may interfere with the loader, though minor modifications or switching to revolver grips designed with speedloader compatibility can usually resolve this. It's worth testing with snap caps or at the range before competition use.
How does the Comp I release mechanism work?
Instead of twisting a knob, you simply align the six cartridges with your cylinder and press down. When the loader contacts the ejector rod, the spring-loaded ratchet automatically releases all the rounds into the cylinder at once. It's a faster, hands-down approach compared to other speedloader designs.
Is this loader suitable for both .44 Magnum and .44 Special?
Yes, it handles both .44 Magnum and .44 Special ammunition. The J-S5 is designed to work with either caliber in compatible N-Frame revolvers, so whether you're shooting full-power magnum loads or Special rounds, the loader will function the same way.
What makes this Comp I smaller than other speedloaders?
The low-profile knob and compact polymer design are key to its size. Safariland engineered the Comp I to be the smallest conventional speedloader they make, which is why it's popular for concealed carry and those who don't want bulk in their range bag or holster setup.
Can I carry this loaded in a holster pouch?
Yes, many people carry loaded Comp I speedloaders in belt pouches or range bags. The rounds stay locked in place during normal carry and won't accidentally dump unless you press them into a cylinder. Speedloader pouches are widely available if you want dedicated carry options.
How does Safariland Comp I compare to HKS loaders?
The main difference is the release mechanism. Comp I uses automatic spring-loaded release when pressed into the cylinder, while HKS requires a twist of a knob. Comp I users often cite faster reloads and a simpler motion. Both are reliable, so preference comes down to whether you prefer the push-release action or the twist-knob approach.





Reviews
There are no reviews yet.